As is usually the case when indie darlings turn into symphonic beat-bearers for the calm-wave set, this album was derided with impossible expectations and flaunted as a failure upon its release in 2010. But if all you're looking for is a rehash of the early angular proto-prog-punk that made Blonde Redhead dreamboats for the critical acclaim they only sometimes actually got-- you're actually missing the point. Penny Sparkle doesn't nod in that direction at all. In fact, if you were to place 1997's Fake Can Be Just As Good beside Penny Sparkle to do a side-by-side comparison you'd actually believe it even less that the same band recorded both records. Have I used enough hyphens yet?
That's the thing with Blond Redhead. They've always had a weird, mysterious edge. As much as we're all tempted to turn away in disapproval over the sedated (read: BORING) sound of Penny Sparkle, a cursory listen doesn't even begin to reveal the charms it carries. This is an album that needs a soaking period. Actually I've only just started appreciating the album for what it is, and I've been trying since it was released. Maybe it's because I am laying in bed at 1:05 am and I've got the munchies. Maybe not. Stay with me, I promise I'll explain.
Penny Sparkle. The name itself has a certain ring to it. At once an atiquated image, and at once a mood descriptor, it functions on many levels. Even if you don't derive any meaning from the title, once you start unpacking the sound of the record, there's a duality obviously at play. What should Blonde Redhead be, now that they've proven they can triangulate the shit out of a slanted pop hook? What can they conjure with their arguably outdated (but still cool as hell) bag of tricks?
Well, conjure they certainly do. This album is probably the most mysteriously deceptive of any in their canon. Really. Don't believe what all the "fans" told you, this isn't Blonde Redhead: The Senile Years just yet. No, Penny Sparkle revolves and revokes itself from view. It spins and shatters, repeats and replays, and the trance it creates is hard to ignore. That doesn't mean it's an easy record to love, or even to appreciate. No, you have to shut out the world, and tune in. You have to breathe and close your eyes, you have to dive and take a chance. Let your guard down. Sit in awhile. Stop hurrying to the next track. This album deserves a full spin and a rainy day. If that makes any sense.
Blond Redhead have finalized their conversion to synthesizers and drum machines. We all saw this coming, and we all decided if we liked this side of the band a long time ago. If you do, you'll find charms aplenty peppered all over Penny Sparkle. If you didn't, you probably won't stick around long enough to find them. But it's still your call.
